Sourdough Starter Not Rising!: Plus 17 Common Problems & Fail-Proof Solutions

Did you know that over 72% of new sourdough bakers face starter issues in their first month? Don’t worry – you’re not alone! As an experienced baker and sourdough enthusiast, I’ve encountered (and solved) nearly every starter problem imaginable. Is your sourdough starter not rising, smelly, or showing strange colors? This comprehensive sourdough starter troubleshooting guide will help diagnose and fix your sourdough starter issues. Let’s bring your starter back to bubbling life!

Signs of a Healthy Sourdough Starter

One of the first signs that your starter is thriving is bubbles. Lots of them! Look for small, uniform bubbles on the surface and throughout the mixture. They indicate active fermentation, which is what makes your starter spring to life. If your jar has a clear side, you should also see bubbles rising up the glass—like little air elevators.

Another clue? The dome shape of the starter after a good feeding. A happy starter will peak with a slightly rounded top, almost like the surface of freshly whipped cream. When it starts to flatten out or collapse, that’s your cue it’s hungry again. Oh, and texture matters too. It should look fluffy, airy, and light—not watery or dense.

Expected Rise and Fall Patterns

A healthy starter goes through predictable cycles. After feeding, you’ll see it begin to rise within 2 to 4 hours, depending on the temperature of your kitchen (cooler environments slow things down). At its peak, it can double, sometimes even triple, in volume. This is where I used to panic—thinking it would overflow if I didn’t bake fast enough. Spoiler: it’s okay if it falls. The starter will naturally deflate after it peaks, which is totally normal and part of the cycle.

The key is learning its rhythm. Mine usually rises for about 4-6 hours before falling, but it varies based on the flour I use, the amount of unfed starter I added, and the room temp. (If it’s taking longer or not rising at all, it might need a little warmth or a more frequent feeding schedule.)

Normal Aroma Profiles at Different Stages

Here’s where your nose comes in. A thriving starter has a distinct smell that evolves as it ferments. Right after feeding, it should smell fresh and slightly sweet—like yogurt or freshly kneaded dough. As it matures, the aroma will become tangy, with hints of apple cider vinegar or even beer. That tangy smell tells you that the wild yeast and bacteria are hard at work.

If it smells like nail polish remover or straight-up funky gym socks, it might be over-fermenting. Don’t toss it yet! Try feeding it more often to balance things out. (Trust me, I saved mine from smelling like acetone once—it just needed some TLC.)

Typical Activity Timeline After Feeding

Here’s what you can expect in a normal feeding cycle:

• 0–2 hours: Starter looks calm, maybe with a few tiny bubbles starting to form.
• 2–4 hours: Noticeable rise, bubbles spreading across the surface, and a slightly sweet aroma.
• 4–8 hours: Starter peaks, becoming light, airy, and bubbly. This is prime time for baking.
• 8–12 hours: It begins to deflate as fermentation slows, developing a tangier smell.
• 12–24 hours: If left unfed, it may start looking sluggish or develop a watery layer (hooch), which just means it’s hungry.

Proper Consistency and Appearance Benchmarks

Here’s where I messed up early on—I kept adding too much water, so my starter was basically pancake batter. Don’t be me! The consistency should be closer to thick cake batter—scoopable but still a bit stretchy. If it’s too thin, it’ll ferment too quickly and collapse. If it’s too thick, the yeast might struggle to do its thing.

A well-fed starter will look creamy, with a matte finish when you stir it. After stirring down a risen starter, it should still feel airy but not completely collapsed into a puddle.

Signs Your Sourdough Starter Is Not Healthy

If your sourdough starter isn’t thriving, there are clear signs to watch for that indicate something is off:

• Foul smell or off-putting odor: A healthy starter should have a pleasantly tangy, yeasty aroma. If it starts to smell like dirty socks, vinegar, or worse, it’s a sign that something is wrong.
• No bubbles or signs of fermentation: Bubbles are a visual indicator of active fermentation. If your starter appears flat and lifeless, it may not be alive and well.
• Discoloration or presence of mold: White, black, or green spots on the surface signal mold growth, which is dangerous and cannot be salvaged.
• Excessive liquid (hooch) forming on top: A layer of liquid, known as hooch, is a sign that the starter is hungry or neglected. While hooch isn’t harmful, it does indicate the need for immediate attention.

Recognizing these symptoms early can help you address potential problems before your starter becomes unusable.

Common Problems and How to Fix Them

Even healthy starters can experience occasional hiccups. So, what is the biggest mistake you can make with your sourdough starter? Here’s a breakdown of common sourdough starter problems and how to resolve them effectively.

1. Why is my sourdough starter not rising?

Causes:
This issue often happens due to inactive yeast, improper temperatures, or an irregular feeding schedule. Yeast thrives in warm, consistent environments, and any extreme deviations can slow down its activity.

Solutions:
Start by adjusting the feeding ratio—try doubling the amount of flour and water for a boost. Ensure your starter is kept in a spot with a temperature range of 70-78°F, as yeast activity slows down in cooler environments. If you’re using tap water, switch to filtered or dechlorinated water to avoid chemicals that can harm the microbes.

2. How do I fix my starter that smells like acetone?

Causes:
Overfermentation and infrequent feedings can lead to an overly sour or unpleasant-smelling starter. When the yeast has consumed all available food, the metabolic byproducts can create undesirable odors.

Solutions:
Discard the majority of the starter, leaving just a small amount—around 1-2 tablespoons. Feed it with equal parts flour and water more frequently, ideally once or twice a day. This refreshes the starter and balances its microbial activity.

3. What’s on top of my starter? There’s a layer of liquid on top (hooch)

Causes:
Hooch forms when the starter is left unfed for too long, signaling that it is “hungry” and running out of food.

Solutions:
Stir the hooch back into the starter to retain the natural flavor, or pour it off if the liquid seems excessive. Feed your starter more frequently going forward—every 12 hours for a while—to bring it back to full health.

4. Is it OK if my sourdough starter has mold?

Causes:
Mold is often the result of poor hygiene or storing the starter in an unsanitary or contaminated environment.

Solutions:
Unfortunately, if mold appears on your starter, the safest option is to discard it entirely and start fresh. To prevent this, always use clean utensils, sterilized containers, and fresh ingredients when maintaining your starter.

5. What to do if my sourdough is too runny?

Causes:
Achieving the right consistency is all about the ratio of water to flour. A starter that’s too runny or overly thick signals an imbalance in this ratio.

Solutions:
Adjust your feedings until your starter resembles a thick pancake batter. For a runny starter, add slightly less water during feeding. For an overly thick one, increase the water slightly until the desired texture is achieved.

6. Why has my starter stopped rising?

Causes:
Flour changes, changes in the environment’s temperature, or inconsistent feeding schedules can change your starter’s behavior.

Solutions:
Refresh your flour supply (it might be old), check water temperature (room temp is best), and ensure consistent feeding times. Try adding some whole grain flour to boost activity.

7. How to fix a sourdough starter that is too sour?

Causes:
Keeping too much starter between feedings, warm storage, over-fermentation, or a high proportion of whole-grain flours.

Solutions:
Feed more frequently, keep at a cooler temperature, and/or increase the feeding ratio. Use white flour instead of whole grain for milder flavor.

8. Why is my sourdough starter not sour enough?

Causes:
Too frequent feedings, too cold storage temperature, using only white flour, young or immature starter, or insufficient fermentation time.

Solutions:
Feed less frequently, use more whole grain flour, and/or keep at a warmer temperature. Allow to ferment longer between feedings.

9. Why is my sourdough starter forming a crust on top?

Causes:
Low humidity environment, insufficient container coverage, air circulation too high, container too wide, dry environment, or extended exposure to air.

Solutions:
Keep it covered more tightly or use a lid with a small vent. You can also mist the top with water after feeding.

10. Why does it take so long for my sourdough starter to rise?

Causes:
Sourdough starters are very dependent on temperatures. Cold room temperature and cold water used in feeding can delay your starter’s activity. Other causes for your sourdough starter not rising are weak yeast population, over-fermented starter, insufficient feeding ratio, poor quality flour, or too much competition from acid-producing bacteria.

Solutions:
Keep it covered more tightly or use a lid with a small vent. You can also mist the top with water after feeding.

11. Why does my sourdough starter smell rotten?

Causes:
The wrong type of bacteria colonization, contaminated flour or water, poor hygiene during feeding, too warm storage temperature, anaerobic conditions, contaminated container or utensils.

Solutions:
Bad bacteria have taken over. Discard and start fresh, ensuring clean equipment and good quality ingredients.

12. What is the grey tinge on my sourdough starter?

Causes:
Your starter is oxidizing from exposure to air or minerals in water.

Solutions:
This is usually oxidation. Stir it back in during feeding. If it persists, try feeding more frequently or adjusting your flour mix.

13. Why is my sourdough starter expanding too much?

Causes:
Wrong flour-to-starter ratios, not enough discard during feedings, or your environment is too warm.

Solutions:
Maintain a smaller amount by discarding more before feeding. Keep only what you need based on your baking schedule.

14. What do big bubbles mean in sourdough starter?

Causes:
Over-fermentation, too long between feedings, too warm storage temperature, protein breakdown from extended fermentation, or uneven mixing during feeding.

Solutions:
This often indicates overfermentation. Feed more frequently or reduce the time between feedings. Adjust your flour-to-water ratio if needed.

15. Why does my sourdough starter keep separating?

Causes:
Mixing techniques can cause a starter to separate. It could also be due to incorrect hydration levels, protein breakdown, or temperature fluctuations.

Solutions:
Feed more frequently, stir more vigorously when feeding, and ensure your ratios are consistent. Consider reducing hydration slightly.

16. Why does my sourdough starter smell like alcohol?

Causes:
Extended fermentation without feeding, too warm storage temperature, too much time between feedings, excess fermentation of sugars, wrong bacteria balance, too little fresh flour relative to mature starter.

Solutions:
Your starter is over-fermented. Discard all but a small amount and feed with fresh flour and water. Increase feeding frequency.

17. Why is my sourdough so thick?

Causes:
Most likely caused by the type of flour you are using or incorrect ratios. Other causes are humidity changes in the environment or new flour brands being used.

Solutions:
Add more water to achieve the desired consistency. Different flours absorb water differently, so adjust your hydration ratio accordingly. Keep notes on what works best with your flour choice.

Tips for Preventing Sourdough Starter Issues

Disclaimer: As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases.

Prevention is the easiest way to maintain a thriving sourdough starter. These tips can help you avoid common pitfalls:

• Maintain a consistent feeding schedule: Feed your starter once or twice daily, depending on how active it is and how often you plan to use it.
• Keep the starter in an optimal temperature range: Aim for 70-78°F, and avoid leaving the starter in areas prone to temperature fluctuations.
• Use high-quality, unbleached flour: Bleached flour can inhibit microbial growth, so opt for unbleached and preferably organic flour for the best results. One of the best out there is King Arthur’s organic unbleached bread flour.
• Use clean utensils and containers: Always handle your starter with clean tools to reduce the risk of contamination and mold growth.

By sticking to these best practices, you can enjoy a healthy, robust sourdough starter that’s ready to rise to the occasion.

FAQs

How do I know if my starter is dead?

If your starter shows no signs of life—no bubbles, no rise, and no smell—after consistent feeding for several days, it is likely dead. You’ll need to start a new culture from scratch.

Can I revive a neglected starter?

Yes, many neglected starters can be revived! Start by discarding most of the starter and feeding it with fresh flour and water. Be patient—feed it daily for up to a week to see if it begins to show signs of life.

What’s the difference between hooch and mold?

Hooch is a harmless liquid that forms when the starter is hungry, and it can be stirred back in or poured off. Mold, on the other hand, appears as fuzzy or colored spots and indicates contamination. Moldy starters must be discarded immediately.

Can I use my starter if it smells like alcohol?

Yes, an alcohol-like smell is caused by the presence of hooch and is a sign that the starter is hungry. Discard some of the starter and feed it regularly to restore its balance.

Conclusion

A healthy sourdough starter is the foundation of great bread, but it requires care and attention to thrive. Troubleshooting common issues—and learning how to prevent them—ensures your starter stays lively and active. Don’t be afraid to experiment, adjust, and learn as you go. With patience and practice, you’ll master the art of maintaining a vibrant sourdough starter.

If you’re just beginning your sourdough journey, check out our beginner-friendly sourdough guide for additional tips and recipes. Happy baking!